A classic Dickinson story comes to life again in Tim West’s adaptation of A Christmas Carol. This time, the director leans as close as he can to his horror-genre staples before getting over its M rating here in Australia.
Spooky, yes, some jump scares indeed, and possibly not for the kids. But as much as this film sticks to the source material and has distinguishing flourishes like 35mm, generally good production design, an original score, and a supporting cast, it utterly fails in its choice to put Johnny Depp in the lead.
The core narrative is what you’d expect for the classic story of Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp). He’s a cruelly old man who holds on to his riches, looks down on the poor and needy, treats everyone in his life and only remaining family, his nephew Fred (Sam Claflin), terribly and whose journey from ruthless, stuck-up to newly born good man is as classic a story and character arc as they come. However, to do justice to that story, you need a believable Ebenezer and an actor who can show that journey, which Depp does not manage at all.

Over the course of one night, Ebenezer is visited by three ghosts: the ghost of Christmas Past, Christmas Present and Christmas Yet-To-Come. Herein, visiting memories, unseen realities, and futures to come, he sees the rather wretched life he’s built for himself, and a tough childhood here and there for his behaviour. By the time you get to the final act, the clarity is supposed to be there, but when you compare Depp to the supporting cast, it’s like he’s acting in a completely different movie.
Perhaps the biggest mistake wasn’t casting Depp; maybe it is the strong cast around him that makes his performance falter even more. None stronger than Sir Ian McKellen as Scrooge’s partner who dies in the prologue,
Jacob Marley leaves Scrooge alone until he visits him as a ghost and prepares him for the night to come. Marley being as big a rotton-old-soul as Scrooge, you can only wish he was playing the lead instead. Even amidst the film’s earliest scenes, the two sit across from each other at desks, apparently acting in entirely different realms.
Clafin brings charm and warmth to his role, as does Rupert Grint as Scrooge’s remaining employee. What Ti West does with the ghosts is some of this film’s strongest points. Andrea Riseborough is haunting as a ghastly Ghost of Christmas Past, and Tramell Tillman is a giant-like figure from another time as the Ghost of Christmas Present. The two are some of the most interesting takes on these characters I’ve seen on screen. There’s backstory to them; you get a sense of where and what times they’ve come from; the haunting memories that seep from the back of their minds; the chains that keep them in this “job.”
And then there’s Deep bouncing off them like playdough hitting something in an art museum.
Ebenezer
The score by Tyler Bates is fantastic, with some twists on classic pieces; the cinematography from Checco Varese brings this Victorian era to life; it's genuinely a very good-looking film. And amongst it, with some tweaks, tightening of the script to get it closer to ninety minutes, and someone else with the ability to make Scrooge's journey believable, a good, maybe great take on A Christmas Carol, but this isn't it.
Comments